Convertible car rental alternatives in Fishers, IN

Better value, better cars

Wherever your trip takes you, book the perfect car, conveniently and affordably.

Convenient delivery

Get your car delivered to you, saving time and hassle

The perfect car

Choose the exact car you want — from swishy sports cars to sturdy sedans

More bang for your buck

Book a better car for up to 35% less than traditional car rental agencies

Average ratings in Fishers (5 stars)

Roy
Tesla Model 3 2018
I have rented a few Teslas and this was the easiest process and the best Model 3 I've personally driven. If you're on the fence, just do it. They're the coolest car you'll ever drive.
Roy S. - February 19, 2020
Robert
Volvo S60 2015
Great communication, quick response time, nice and clean car, and extremely easy pick-up/drop-off.
Robert B. - February 3, 2020
Christina
Toyota Prius 2010
This was my first time using Turo and while it was a little different from the typical car rental place, the app was easy to use and the flexibility was great! My personal car decided not to start at 10:30 at night and I had to be somewhere at 6:00am...I was in a panic and found Turo by searching for a 24 hour car rental place. I called and David answered and sent me the link to the app and within an hour I was meeting him to get a rental! It worked out great for me and I will be renting from David again later this week and in the future as well!
Christina S. - July 9, 2019
Gregory Michael
Tesla Model S 2013
A first-class experience is hard to quantify, but that in part is what makes it amazing. I recently had the good fortune to book Steve’s dark grey 2013 Model S 85 for a business trip to Nashville. Here’s why I recommend not only this car, but any car offered by Steve: 1. On my way to pick up, the GPS directions used by my Uber driver missed the mark by (literally) a mile. I messaged Steve, and almost immediately received a phone call from him. After figuring out where I was, he sent one of his employees to pick me up! So I hadn’t even got to the car and he had already (again, literally) gone the extra mile. 2. This car is amazing. Not just because Teslas are a special breed of awesome, but because it was so well maintained and clean. It was basically like a brand new car. 3. Steve provides great instructions if you’re a first time Tesla driver, and provided some especially useful advice about battery range behavior for longer trips. I’d have spent a lot more time waiting around at Superchargers if he hadn’t shared his knowledge. 4. Driving a Tesla, if you haven’t, will permanently ruin ICE cars for you. I miss the car and am officially saving up to buy one after that trip. Torque on demand, smooth ride, unexpectedly-convenient and cool convenience features, these cars have it all. My favorite feature was the cruise control, which allows you to add or subtract 1 or 5 mph by tapping a lever in finger’s reach from the left of the wheel (above the turn signal) up or down to varying degrees. It’s hard to explain, but when you drive one, it feels like a new kind of thing. The next step after what we currently think of as ‘car’. And at the price Steve lists it, it’s less costly than a stripped-down fleet rental from Budget. (Still reading? Reserve this car before someone else does!) 5. I got a late start the day I was supposed to return the car, and Steve immediately approved my extension request! I got to enjoy the drive home knowing I wasn’t going to have to rush thanks to that. 6. Returning the car was a breeze, and the same gentleman that gave me a lift at the start of the trip drove me back to my apartment downtown at Steve’s behest! (Plus, he took me in the Tesla, so I got to spend a little more time with that miracle machine.) So recap: Great car. Extra-mile customer experience. Near-immediate communication and responsiveness. Almost too-good-to-be-true price. Flexibility? Check. Plus, Teslas are like time-traveling little spaceships from a way more awesome future. All in all, to call it a great experience would be a gross understatement. Next time I need a car for a business trip, I’m looking for this one first, and anything else listed by Steve second. Highly recommended. PS - Forgot to mention, this car comes with free supercharging, so when doing price comparisons, don’t forget to include how much you’ll otherwise spend on gas in your calculations, and write $0.00 next to the Tesla. PPS - Thanks Steve! You rock!!
Gregory Michael L. - September 17, 2018
mark
Honda Insight 2014
I have rented vehicles from David three separate times now < a month rental each of the first two times, and this last time, I rented this vehicle herein for almost 2 1/2 months. David is the BEST! EXCELLENT communication, punctuality, flexibility, and beyond EASY pick-up and return. You will not go wrong renting a vehicle from David. He is honest, a great communicator and truly loyal to TURO and making it better for everyone. The vehicle herein that I rented for 2 1/2 months was EXCELLENT. Great vehicle that was in top notch shape and was very clean and very comfortable when driving it. In fact, for my rental, David had put on 4 brand new tires. Moreover, I made several different trips during my 2 1/2 month rental and the car was great to drive on interstates and VERY smooth and enjoyable. In addition, you save a lot on gas with this vehicle! Anytime, i am back in Indianapolis, i only have one" go to person," and that is David....period! I HIGHLY, HIGHLY RECOMMEND HIM !
Mark F. - August 25, 2019
David
Tesla Model 3 2018
Great car and friendly owner to work with. Will plan to rent again.
David H. - December 23, 2019
David
Tesla Model 3 2018
Awesome car and great host! Second Tesla I have rented and Patrick really explained everything more clearly then with my last one. Felt much more comfortable and was able to use every feature. I really felt I experienced Tesla ownership from charging to use of all the advanced features👍😎
David A. - December 18, 2019
Tlotlo
Volvo S60 2015
This was my trip with Turo and Josmon was the absolute perfect host! He made my trip a breeze and was easily available for any questions I had. This is an amazing car and I’m extremely pleased. Will definitely be using his services in the near future!
Tlotlo W. - January 20, 2020
Sandra
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
David has been the absolute best to work with. The care is awesome! Not enough stars to rate how good this rental experience has been. Thank you David!
Sandra T. - October 30, 2018
Robert
Toyota Prius 2016
David is one of the best owners that I have rented from. He was totally accommodating, offering me an alternative car when there was a timing problem picking up. Then when my trip was going badly, he rearranged things again, allowing me an extended extension. Thanks David!
Robert B. - April 2, 2019
Dwight
Toyota Prius 2016
This was my first time using Turo, and I loved it. Its much better than using the standard rental companies. David made renting the car quick and easy. The car ran smooth and had all the cool features you expect in a new car. I will definetely be a returning customer on my next trip. Thanks, David.
Dwight C. - May 27, 2019
Kimberly
Honda Insight 2010
Pick-up and drop-off for the vehicle was very convenient. I love the car and it drove excellent! I felt like David was very easy to contact if I had any issues or questions! I would definitely rent from him again! Renting through turo from David definitely took a lot of stress out of my trip!
Kimberly G. - October 23, 2019
Patrick
Toyota Prius 2016
David made this experience wonderful and extremely easy. He had a great selection of Prius’s and I was very impressed with the fuel economy, it was so simple and inexpensive to rent. I will definitely rent from him in the future!
Patrick O. - December 20, 2019
Rome
Tesla Model 3 2018
Amazing car and matching owner. Very pleased. Thank you for the opportunity.
Rome T. - December 2, 2019
Pete
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick is awesome!! I could not have had a better experience with a better car! I highly recommend him and his Tesla!
Pete S. - January 18, 2020
Ben
Toyota Prius 2010
Very clean car in good condition
Ben W. - January 6, 2020
Colin
Tesla Model 3 2018
Travis was so kind and flexible. I was excited to be the first person to have rented his vehicle. It was absolutely gorgeous. The car is so incredibly fun to drive and has insanely cool tech including partial auto pilot. I highly recommend renting this Model 3, especially from Travis! His kindness and hospitality make renting the car all the more awesome.
Colin K. - October 10, 2018
Bob
Tesla Model 3 2018
Travis was awesome! He gave me a a very good overview of how the car works before my trip. The Tesla Model 3 is an amazing car to drive! I definitely would recommend Travis!
Bob T. - October 20, 2018
Deion
Honda Insight 2010
This is my 3rd time renting from David and he is always nice and flexible with you. Cars are great as well! Thanks David! 👍🏾
Deion P. - February 28, 2019
DeLynn
Toyota Prius 2016
Second rental with David. Very flexible and easy to work with. Nice car with good price.
DeLynn H. - September 22, 2018
Gregory Michael
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick was great to work with and the car is not to be missed. Fantastic for business trips, or for anyone curious what it’s like to drive one of these remarkable cars. Highly recommended.
Gregory Michael L. - February 20, 2019
Khara
Toyota Prius 2016
David has great cars for rent. Super easy pick up and return. Would gladly rent from him again and again!
Khara O. - June 23, 2019
Kelsey
Toyota Prius 2016
David was professional, courteous and flexible. The vehicle was clean, well kept and a pleasure to drive. I wish more hybrid car rentals were available in the area.
Kelsey F. - May 11, 2019
Amethyst
Toyota Prius 2016
This was my first time using Turo & David has definitely set a standard that I hope others can reach. The car was clean, ready when he said & in an easy spot to locate. His communication is amazing & he is very accommodating. He was flexible & considerate when a problem arose for which he didn’t have to be nice about but was. I will do my best to ONLY rent from him. He made me comfortable and he is very gracious. If you’re going to rent from anyone, try to rent from David, you won’t be disappointed. He’s a sweetheart & I appreciate him more than I could express.
Amethyst C. - May 27, 2019
Thuan
Porsche 718 Boxster 2017
I had a wonderful experience with this rental! Erik was very responsive! Highly recommend.
Thuan H. - October 2, 2019
Frank
Honda S2000 2007
Great host! David provides a variety of cars and was flexible with my trip requests as my itinerary changed. This is how Turo is supposed to be done - he should write a manual for others!
Frank C. - June 29, 2019
Donisty
Volkswagen Jetta 2014
Josmon was great! Very thorough from start to finish, I had no questions at all! I even picked the car up after midnight and it was completely accessible with the given instructions. The Jetta was the perfect car for a two day visit back home, also pretty good on gas! I only had to fill up when returning the car and I drove quite a bit. All in all, a great experience- 5 stars and will ONLY be renting with Josmon every time I’m in town. Thank you thank you thank you!!!!
Donisty H. - November 8, 2019
Evan
Volkswagen Jetta 2014
Process was smooth and easy. Great communication. I’ll definitely use his services again. Thanks Josmon
Evan W. - November 30, 2019
Gary
Porsche 718 Boxster 2017
The car is truly extraordinary, and Erik made the process of renting very easy.
Gary G. - September 6, 2018
Sarah
Tesla Model S 2013
Steve is so nice and was really helpful throughout my trip! He was always quick to answer any questions I had and was really thorough with showing me the details on the car. The Tesla was such a fun treat to drive too. Thank you so much for an awesome experience!
Sarah H. - September 19, 2018
Micah
Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution 2014
Excellent trip once again! The modifications to the Evo really give it a nice touch. Will definitely rent again!
Micah S. - November 14, 2018
Armand
Toyota Corolla 2016
David was very pleasant and flexible. I'll definitely rent from David in the future. Thank you for making my first trip with Turo amazing!
Armand B. - March 23, 2019
Chris
Tesla Model 3 2018
Lots of fun renting a Tesla. Travis was a great host. I will do this again. Thanks!
Chris D. - December 10, 2018
Brianna
Toyota Prius 2010
Renting with David was great! The Prius has amazing gas mileage and he made communication very easy. The pick up and return was a breeze! Definitely recommend his rental 👍🏽
Brianna G. - October 28, 2018
Zachary W
Audi A4 2013
Josmon was amazing, great service, friendly and nice ride. Car was perfect. Will rent again!!
Zachary W S. - December 29, 2018
Nate
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick went above and beyond to make me feel welcomed to Indy and to the Tesla. This was my first experience with the Tesla and he showed me step by step everything I needed to know and I felt more then comfortable visiting my family and let me tell you autopilot was amazing. I would highly recommend this car for anyone and the communication was easy with Patrick anytime I had a question. I will be renting with him the next time I come back to Indy.
Nate C. - January 1, 2019
Kenneth
Tesla Model 3 2018
Travis was a true pleasure to deal with.
Kenneth K. - December 5, 2018
Leslie
Porsche 718 Boxster 2017
Erik was very accommodating and very easy to deal with! We had a great time and would rent from Erik again!
Leslie H. - September 22, 2018
Alan
Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution 2014
Renting Chun's car was a great experience. The car was very enjoyable to drive, extremely well kept and a a real head turner. Chun's communication was flawless. He was quick to respond and a very gracious host.
Alan T. - September 30, 2018
Aakash
Toyota Prius 2016
It was an amazing experience. A fantastic car and very easy to drive. Moreover David was very helpful and easy to get in contact throughout my trip. Thanks David! 👍🏻
Aakash S. - October 16, 2018
Tamika Ayanna
Honda Insight 2010
The best experience with Turo has been with David. Great vehicle on gas and made it easy for pickup and drop off. Will definitely rent from David again!!!
Tamika Ayanna R. - October 14, 2018
Sandra
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
Love this car! And David is the best host. A+++
Sandra T. - January 7, 2019
Tejesh
Toyota Corolla 2016
David is an amazing host and his car was in a very good condition. The communication with him was prompt and he helped us out with a lot of things. I would definitely rent another car with David.
Tejesh D. - January 13, 2019
Micah
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
Awesome again! The only guy I rent from for leisure... definitely a pleasure to rent from. This is not a joke, I really rent from Davis this much 😂😂
Micah S. - February 5, 2019
Keilynn
Toyota Prius 2010
Amazing host! Needed to take a trip for out of state campus tour and i had no problems! Fast reply, car was roomy, and great on gas!
Keilynn G. - February 21, 2019
Randall
Honda S2000 2007
Rented it as a Father's Day gift. My father enjoyed every minute of it! It's a great little sports car although the exhaust does get a little boomy with the top up.
Randall S. - June 11, 2019
Scott
Tesla Model 3 2018
Cars awesome and Patrick is a super cool nice guy highly recommend
Scott W. - April 21, 2019
Kyle
Tesla Model 3 2018
This car was amazing! Stylish, smooth, & by far one of the nicest cars I've ever experienced. I recommend getting yourself behind the wheel & feeling it for yourself. 5 stars! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Kyle L. - June 16, 2019
Zoheb
Honda S2000 2007
David was great! Car was a fun and really pleasant drive, with a clutch that was pretty light and easy to shift. It was easy to pickup and return the car. One warning if you're relatively new to manuals (like I am). I had no problems driving it (I've been daily driving manual 2 months now, in a Honda Accord), but don't rent it if you've had limited practice - this car idles higher and needs to be pushed harder to get power out on the highway, and for some drivers it may be unnerving to shift at 5-6k RPMs like you need to on the highway, especially since the engine is quite loud. I would not have felt comfortable driving this car if I had even rented this a month ago.
Zoheb N. - June 17, 2019
Sarah
Tesla Model 3 2018
Trip was great. Patrick was great at explaining all the bells and whistles. Would definitely rent again!
Sarah A. - June 25, 2019
Sandra
Honda S2000 2007
GREAT TRIP, FUN CAR !Thank you, David!
Sandra T. - May 13, 2019
Stephen
Tesla Model 3 2018
Awesome car! Awesome host! Originally rented his long range model. That car had an incident, and he was quick to communicate the issue, and get me in his performance model. Made the process easy for me, and will rent from him again in the future .
Stephen O. - June 2, 2019
Makenzie
Toyota Prius 2016
I had a work trip a few hours away and my car was in the shop, so figured I’d try Turo for the first time! Super easy experience thanks to David!
Makenzie S. - May 24, 2019
Kazimir
Honda Insight 2010
The whole process went very smoothly, we had 1250 miles for 6 days which was more than plenty, had great room for all our camping gear and great mileage(about 45mpg) in the Honda hybrid and even was able to use special “hybrid vehicle parking” at the national parks we visited so that was pretty cool. Pick up and drop off were super easy for us and David communicates back very quickly. We had no issues this trip and would be happy to rent from David and Turo again
Kazimir Z. - June 7, 2019
Rea Mae
Honda Insight 2010
Best person to rent from in Indy! Accommodating, flexible, and great communication! Highly recommend! 😊
Rea Mae A. - August 13, 2019
Gary
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick is very knowledgeable about Tesla and his model 3. It was a very easy rental. I'm looking forward to my next vist to Indy so i can rent it again!!
Gary M. - July 15, 2019
Taylor
Honda S2000 2007
The s2000 was awesome, really nice car. Would highly recommend renting from David.
Taylor C. - July 30, 2019
Anthony
Honda S2000 2007
The S2000 was everything I expected will rent this car again and from David in the future!
Anthony C. - July 7, 2019
Sandra
Honda S2000 2007
So good to rent from, car is fantastic
Sandra T. - July 10, 2019
Sheilah
Volkswagen Jetta 2014
Josmon was such a great host. It was my first time renting through him and he was so flexible, so understanding, so punctual, and so friendly. The car was great and had no problems. I highly recommend renting through josmon! 10/10 experience and I will definitely be back!
Sheilah W. - August 28, 2019
Amanda
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick was awesome! He was very flexible and willing to work with me to surprise my daughter for her birthday. His car is amazing and he took the time to show me everything. The car was spotless too. Had a great time. Highly recommend!
Amanda C. - September 9, 2019
Joe
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick was an excellent host. The Model 3 was an absolute dream to drive from Indiana to South Carolina. There were plenty of superchargers through Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia, and North Carolina. Many thanks to Patrick for a memorable Fall Break.
Joe A. - October 23, 2019
Jasmine
Volkswagen Jetta 2014
Very positive. Great personality, friendly, outgoing. The car is great! Really enjoy it
Jasmine G. - November 3, 2019
Jan
Volkswagen Jetta 2014
Communication was great and responds fast! Highly recommend renting through them!
Jan O. - October 29, 2019
Shirley
Tesla Model 3 2018
That car was an absolute blast to drive. It reminded me of my 55 Chevy I used to have when I was a teenager. The stereo in the car is outstanding. And the beautiful thing about the car smoke-free. Patrick is very friendly and very helpful with the car. We went to Costcos and loaded the car down with groceries. I would love to have a car like this.
Shirley F. - October 28, 2019
Daniel
Porsche 718 Boxster 2017
Great car, made the day special. Erik was easy to communicate with and pickup and drop off was quick and easy as well.
Daniel F. - October 23, 2019
Stephanie
Volkswagen Jetta 2014
Nice guy and car drove great. He was very flexible with pickup and drop off too.
Stephanie B. - November 25, 2019
Peter
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
The Shelby GT 350 was awesome. The owner was easy to work with even when my flight was delayed prior to picking up the car
Peter W. - October 21, 2018
Sandra
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
Perfect every time. Great car and David is awesome to work with. Thank you, David!
Sandra T. - November 10, 2018
Yvonne
Toyota Prius 2010
I would definitely rent from David again! He really made sure I had a great experience.
Yvonne A. - October 12, 2018
Demetrius
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick went above and beyond to walk me through the whole process, being this was my first time renting on Turo. He kept in contact and was quick and concise, even when he was experiencing very pressing family matters! The Model 3 is an amazing vehicle, and renting it gave me confidence in my purchase of one. Patrick is wonderful to speak with and someone you can call a friend and is a testament to the future of the Turo platform and renting.
Demetrius V. - March 26, 2019
Rea Mae
Honda Insight 2010
The car was in good condition and David was very accommodating and flexible!
Rea Mae A. - March 8, 2019
Theodore
Tesla Model 3 2018
Travis was an excellent host. Easy to reach, fast to reply, and checks in to make sure everything is going well. Spends a lot of time making sure you are comfortable with the ride before sending you off. Thanks again for the wonderful experience.
Theodore C. - March 12, 2019
Jason
Porsche 718 Boxster 2017
Awesome experience! Erik was a great host and the car was extremely fun to drive!
Jason Y. - March 27, 2019
Mark
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
Super convenient, friendly, and easy from start to finish. Car was a blast to experience - highly recommend!
Mark S. - October 28, 2018
Scott
Tesla Model 3 2018
Great car, Patrick was awesome. Super helpful with pickup and drop off.
Scott W. - January 4, 2019
Aaron
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
Super easy guy to deal with. I recommend him to anybody!!!
Aaron G. - January 1, 2019
Crystal
Toyota Prius 2016
David was prompt in responding. Very helpful. The car was clean. Spotless I would definitely use David again!!!!! THANK YOU!!!
Crystal S. - April 3, 2019
James
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick spend time to explain how the Model 3 is working and also provided recommendation for the trip. The ride was great too, travel from Indy to Ann Arbor MI for the weekend.
James K. - April 7, 2019
Giridhar
Toyota Prius 2016
OMG this car is a rocket and real sharp and drives like a cloud. Awesome car !
Giridhar B. - April 11, 2019
Daniel
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
David’s car was awesome to drive. David was an awesome lender easy pickup and return.
Daniel M. - November 25, 2018
thomas
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick is a great host. He communicated very well, and spent a lot of time going over the Tesla and all the options. The car was in wonderful and clean shape, and of course, it was fun to drive.
Thomas H. - January 29, 2019
Arman
Toyota Prius 2010
David is very easy to work with. Clear communication and the car is great on gas.
Arman K. - January 25, 2019
Galib
Tesla Model 3 2018
Travis is just wonderful and funny, really enjoyed driving his Tesla.
Galib H. - December 24, 2018
David
Porsche 718 Boxster 2017
Awesome car! I was super surprised by the power of the 2.0L turbo engine. The torque just pull you through the turns with ease. Even in 40deg weather with the top down the heated seats and air kept me toasty when I had to try it with the top down. 🕺👍
David A. - December 24, 2018
Dylan
Tesla Model 3 2018
The car was beyond sick to drive!! I felt like I was in the Future!
Dylan C. - December 26, 2018
Robert
Honda Insight 2014
Our family car broke down and was appointed by a friend to use david. Car was clean and ran great. I will use again in the future
Robert I. - December 28, 2018
Sandeep Reddy
Tesla Model S 2013
Steve provides you with every details of the car to enjoy the Tesla. He is very helpful and replies you quickly to your queries. Awesome Tesla experience. Love to come back again.
Sandeep Reddy M. - September 24, 2018
Jonathon
Ford Shelby GT350 2017
It was an awesome experience in an great car! He was prompt in communicating and flexible with arrangements.
Jonathon F. - October 4, 2018
Andrew
Tesla Model 3 2018
Amazing ride! Patrick was gracious and friendly. Will definitely rent again.
Andrew G. - January 13, 2019