Convertible car rental alternatives in Tisbury, MA

Better value, better cars

Wherever your trip takes you, book the perfect car, conveniently and affordably.

Convenient delivery

Get your car delivered to you, saving time and hassle

The perfect car

Choose the exact car you want — from swishy sports cars to sturdy sedans

More bang for your buck

Book a better car for up to 35% less than traditional car rental agencies

Average ratings in Tisbury (4.8 stars)

Paul
Hyundai Accent 2015
Brian was great and the car was clean, ready and reliable for our trip.
Paul S. - September 15, 2019
Cindy
Volkswagen Golf 2012
Neven gets 5 Stars for his cute little Golf. Great Island Car. Neven earns bonus points for communication and the ease of the delivery & drop off process. Thanks Neven for a super smooth trip to the Island. I’ll definitely try to use you again in future!
Cindy R. - September 20, 2019
Michael
Ford Mustang 2015
We were in town for a wedding, and Neven made getting around the island a breeze! The car was perfect for a sunny vacation.
Michael R. - September 24, 2019
Tucker
Nissan Altima 2010
Very easy to get ahold of Renato and he was very flexible as we missed our planned ferry. Good cheap option for cruising around the island.
Tucker H. - September 22, 2019
Lauren
Volvo S40 2010
Everything was great, we got in a little later than expected and he was gracious enough to pick us up at the ferry to make the start to our trip easier. Great communication with him throughout our time and would highly recommend this rental to anyone!
Lauren D. - July 23, 2019