Convertible car rental alternatives in Paia, HI

Better value, better cars

Wherever your trip takes you, book the perfect car, conveniently and affordably.

Convenient delivery

Get your car delivered to you, saving time and hassle

The perfect car

Choose the exact car you want — from swishy sports cars to sturdy sedans

More bang for your buck

Book a better car for up to 35% less than traditional car rental agencies

Average ratings in Paia (4.9 stars)

Felicia
Honda Fit 2013
Five stars! This was the easiest pick up and drop off I’ve ever experienced. The car was clean and perfect for cruising the island. I would definitely rent from Tyler again.
Felicia L. - June 12, 2018
Jacob
Toyota Prius 2008
Oliver is geat! Car was very gas efficient & Reliable. I will deffinetely be renting from him the next time I find myself in Maui!
Jacob H. - July 12, 2018
Justin
Nissan Altima 2016
Had a great time with the car. It ran perfectly and Tyler was really easy to deal with. They offered to pick up and drop off at the airport which was so helpful. I highly recommend.
Justin F. - July 26, 2018
Mario
Chevrolet Volt 2013
Great spacious car with great gas mileage. The car will take you anywhere you need to be on the island with no problems. Would rent car again
Mario F. - February 19, 2019
Bret
Chevrolet Volt 2013
Great car! Silent smoothe, easy! Great smile and friendly vibes from oli and naomi! Computer repair web building , kiteboarding specialists as well. Keeping the world sustainable w multiple electric cars!
Bret C. - March 8, 2019
Brandon
Chevrolet Cobalt 2009
Wonderful experience with this rental. Communication and punctuality made this almost effortless.
Brandon M. - October 27, 2018
Jaocb
Chevrolet Volt 2013
It was an amazing experience for me with this car and with Oliver. He responded very quickly to communication, he was timely and provided the vehicle in a clean and well functioning condition. The car was great, it performed well and the fuel efficiency was a big bonus considering how expensive gas can be on Maui. There was tons of space in the trunk for storing snorkeling gear and the weather matting in the car made it easy to not worry about sand and water and any other things that come with traveling Maui. When I return I will most likely be trying to rent this vehicle again and I would recommend it to anyone.
Jaocb B. - December 31, 2018
Melanie
Toyota Prius 2008
Car was fantastic. Easy to drive, park, and saved us a ton on gas!!! We drove it around the island for a week and didn’t even use a full tank. Oliver was very communicative and patient with us during the check in and out process (we were newbies to Turo).
Melanie B. - July 31, 2019
Kenneth
Nissan Altima 2011
Tyler was a pleasure to rent from. Anyone traveling to Maui I would highly recommend using Tyler!
Kenneth F. - July 1, 2018
Jonathan
Toyota Prius 2008
Great first experience with Turo and Oliver. Would rent from him again.
Jonathan L. - November 11, 2018
Sarah
Toyota Prius 2008
The car is great and perfect for the island. Drove the entire Hana highway with no issues! Oliver was also a great first contact on Maui - very friendly and helpful!
Sarah W. - April 11, 2019
Rodney
Nissan Versa 2008
This was a great experience across the board. The car itself ran well, was clean, and we had no problem. The camping gear we added on was perfect! The tent was small, perfect for 2 people who like to cuddle, so great for us. She went the extra mile with some extra blankets and a cooler. Caity really worked with our schedule, too.
Rodney T. - October 1, 2018
Hedda
Chevrolet Cobalt 2009
Great trip with Turo- pick up and drop off were easy and convenient. Would recommend!
Hedda S. - February 24, 2019
Tyler
Chevrolet Cobalt 2009
You get what you get. Good price for Maui. Nice dude. Smooth process.
Tyler E. - October 17, 2018
Kyle
Chevrolet Cobalt 2009
Phil is an amazing person. Thanks Phil!
Kyle P. - December 17, 2018
Samuel
Toyota Prius 2008
Oliver was very kind, flexible, and was a pleasure doing business with. It was nice having the Prius to enhance my Maui experience!
Samuel S. - December 23, 2018