Convertible car rental alternatives in New Haven, CT

Better value, better cars

Wherever your trip takes you, book the perfect car, conveniently and affordably.

Convenient delivery

Get your car delivered to you, saving time and hassle

The perfect car

Choose the exact car you want — from swishy sports cars to sturdy sedans

More bang for your buck

Book a better car for up to 35% less than traditional car rental agencies

Average ratings in New Haven (4.9 stars)

Allison
Hyundai Accent 2016
Pickup was super easy and convenient and Stephen's car was clean and ran smoothly. Perfect for errands or a day trip with friends! If you need to rent a car in the New Haven area, I highly reccomend renting Stephen's car!
Allison C. - September 30, 2019
Konrad
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
My experience renting Tom’s car was great. From the quality and cleanliness of the car all the way to the convenience of being picked up at the train station in New Haven. Would definitely recommend this rental.
Konrad S. - October 9, 2018
Leslie
Honda Civic 2014
Very convenient to where we needed to be in New Haven and a great deal of flexibility. The Honda Civic was as expected and reliable. Good gas mileage. The pick up and drop off were easy. Thank you!
Leslie H. - June 23, 2018
Jeff
Toyota Prius 2011
Bahar was very great and his car was very clean. If I ever need a car rental again I would 100% rent his car again.
Jeff H. - January 5, 2019
Forrest
Subaru Legacy 2015
Levi’s vehicle was perfect! Had to extend my reservation and his quick response and flexibility made the entire experience more than pleasurable. 10/10 highly recommend renting from Levi!
Forrest C. - November 14, 2019
Archit
Hyundai Accent 2016
Great host with clean car! Highly responsive and easy to pickup/ drop off. I would definitely use it again.
Archit J. - December 1, 2019
Wade
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2016
Timothy is the consummate professional...punctual, timely and all around pleasant! Thank you!
Wade M. - December 1, 2019
Jasmine
Hyundai Accent 2016
He was amazing communicates with the times and it’s an amazing car will rent again
Jasmine R. - October 4, 2019
Kimberlee
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
We were in town for a quick trip and Turo was perfect for our plans. Tom was wonderful and his Mini Cooper was awesome! He made pick up and drop off super easy. We love cars and his car was really fun to drive. He also gave us some great pizza places to try during our trip. If we are back in the area, we will definitely rent this car again! You will not regret renting from him!
Kimberlee F. - May 25, 2019
Yaziel
Nissan Leaf 2017
Raul’s car was perfect for our trip. He explained and gave us all the info we needed for the charging stations. You don’t spend money on gas and the charging is easy! He responded quickly to our questions. Will renter again is I’m in the area.
Yaziel J. - July 8, 2019
Yihana
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
The trip with Tom's Mini Cooper was very smooth. Tom was kind enough to do free pick up and delivery, which was very convenient and eliminated the need for costly Ubers to get to and from the car pickup spot. The car is in great shape, and Tom was quick and efficient at going over the pertinent info. I'd rent again.
Yihana R. - July 22, 2019
Tyler
Chevrolet Impala 2017
Stephanie is amazing! I loved the car.
Tyler M. - November 4, 2019
Frank
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2010
This was a really good Turo Rental!! Great communication with Danielle. The car was clean, in great condition and a really fun drive!! If your thinking about doing business with her and her car you won't regret it. I was really happy how well and smooth the whole process was. I recommend 100% Danielle and her Mercedes.
Frank D. - October 8, 2018
Kris
Kia Optima 2007
Great experience renting from Alicia - very communicative and easy pickup/dropoff. Car was perfect for a trip out of NYC. Am sure I'll rent from them again - thank you!
Kris A. - July 21, 2018
Anthony
Honda Civic 2014
This rental was very accommodating and convenient. He offered to come out of his way to drop the car to us and same for the return. We appreciated his flexibility and communication!
Anthony L. - September 4, 2018
Tom
Audi S4 2011
Jake was easygoing and great to deal with, and his car is REALLY nice... excellent combination of luxury and performance. Awesome experience!
Tom H. - September 23, 2018
Laura
Lexus IS 300 2017
Awesome first Turo experience with Elvis! After renting cars from inside NYC for a while, I decided to meet Elvis at the commuter rail in CT and use his car for a weekend getaway. I didn’t get caught in any traffic getting back, plus his car was so fun to drive. 10/10 would recommend!
Laura P. - May 27, 2019
Scott
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom was very communicative and flexible, and his Mini Cooper was a joy to drive. It comfortably fit four people for a drive up and down the Northeast corridor. One small note, just for information: I selected the 'delivery' option for the car to avoid taking a taxi out to the pick-up location. Tom delivered the car promptly to my address, however we had to drive him back to the pick-up location before departing on our trip. Not a huge deal as we weren't on a super tight schedule, but I would recommend meeting directly at the pick-up location if time is sensitive.
Scott S. - June 9, 2019
Leslie
Nissan Maxima 2018
Samantha is rocking this TURO thing ! I was a first time user and she provided a nice vehicle , extended kindness and an overall great experience !! Kudos to her , very accommodating
Leslie B. - September 27, 2019
Brooks
Hyundai Accent 2016
Great drive, very flexible and convenient!
Brooks T. - October 15, 2019
Robbie
Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class 2007
Great host and very classy car. Tom was very accommodating and understanding to any of your needs. This may be the best value car as it’s also a convertible- which is the best in the summer. Great for a ride on the highway and nice for a date night.
Robbie S. - July 28, 2019
Kristina
Chevrolet Malibu 2012
Super convenient location- pick up & drop off were seamless!
Kristina P. - October 21, 2019
Armande
Volkswagen Jetta Hybrid 2013
This the coolest guy you could ever rent from. Everything was smooth from the start to the finish. Hybrid Jetta runs SMOOTH. If you need a vehicle. RENT FROM HIM. Best up here.
Armande E. - October 8, 2018
Eric
Honda Civic 2014
Great guy he gives the best service... i will make sure he be the first i try to rent from before anyone else... his communication is the best and hes always there when you call or need him
Eric H. - June 27, 2018
Forest
Honda Civic 2014
They were flexible with the pickup and return process. The car was in great condition. Would rent again!
Forest P. - June 18, 2018
Siu Lum Zelig
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom and his mini were great. Tom is super courteous, understanding and thorough, even wiped it down once more before we took off. Car was clean, well maintained, and safe for our day trips. Thanks Tom!
Siu Lum Zelig F. - August 24, 2018
John
Audi S4 2011
Jake was an all around cool dude and the car was definitely awesome. Will be renting again.
John H. - September 10, 2018
Erik
Audi S4 2011
Jake was very accommodating and the car was incredible. This was my second time renting from Jake and I'd do it again.
Erik S. - September 17, 2018
Robert
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom's MINI was dope, he picked us up and dropped us off at the train station with no issues, the best Turo experience I've had by far, would definitely rent again next time I'm in CT!
Robert C. - September 17, 2018
Lesche
Lexus IS 300 2017
I enjoyed my trip so much, I didn't want to return the car lol. Thanks so much Elvis for helping me out and even coming earlier than our appointed time. I definitely will be doing business with you again. Thanks
Lesche B. - October 21, 2018
alexandra
Toyota Prius 2011
Great car. Easy to pick up/drop off. I’ll more than likely rent it again soon!
Alexandra B. - October 26, 2018
Susan-Marie
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom's MiniCooper is a beautiful car and a lot of fun to drive. Tom picked me up and dropped me off at the Amtrak station, which was a real plus. Will rent again.
Susan-Marie S. - April 13, 2019
Shannon
Volkswagen Jetta Hybrid 2013
Enjoyed the car and Aquarius was a pleasure to rent from would rent from him again.
Shannon R. - October 15, 2018
Chris
Toyota Corolla 2018
This car has a great active cruise control feature, so it can automatically control the speed on the highway, which made our long distance trip a breeze. Sam was also really great about meeting us at the train station. 5/5
Chris L. - May 20, 2019
Sarah
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2016
Timothy was an amazing host!! He made everything so easy and communicated promptly. His car was so fun to drive and I'd definitely rent with him again!
Sarah D. - May 23, 2019
Melissa
Toyota Prius 2011
Bahar was super kind and accommodating! Great little car. Would rent again!
Melissa G. - May 27, 2019
Jamieson
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2016
Amazing person to rent from and an amazing car to rent! Highly recommend.
Jamieson M. - May 26, 2019
sharnaye
Toyota Corolla 2018
Sam was totally nice and understanding. I will definitely rent her car again anytime. Also I have left a pair of heels in the car and I was contact immediately and she’s holding them for me. Car was good on gas no problems
Sharnaye B. - April 28, 2019
Yolanda
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2016
Had a great trip with this car. Very good communication as well.
Yolanda C. - May 10, 2019
Kiari
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2016
Timothy was awesome! I booked his car a few hours prior to pickup, easy process. I loved the car so much I wanted to extend for an additional day and that was an easy process. The car is very lovely, smooth ride and not too bad on gas. I will definitely be contacting Timothy in the future!! Highly recommended!
Kiari W. - August 20, 2019
Samuel
Ford Fusion 2011
Great car and excellent communication from Darin.
Samuel S. - June 12, 2019
Pavle
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom was very kind, responsive, and understanding when we got stuck in the traffic on our way back. The car is so much fun, very easy to drive and the roof is just great for the summer. It was such a seamless experience and rest assured that booking with Tom is a great decision.
Pavle K. - July 8, 2019
Rachel
Toyota Prius 2011
Terrific host. Car was in great condition. Let us adjust our start and finish time, and even drove us to the train station when we dropped the car off.
Rachel S. - July 8, 2019
Tom
Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class 2007
Tom was great to work with. Perfect car for a weekend getaway!
Tom M. - August 30, 2019
Scott
Chevrolet Malibu 2012
Darin was a great host! Pick up and drop off were easy and seamless. The vehicle was clean and comfortable - I would highly recommend renting from him and I fully intend to again in the future.
Scott S. - August 28, 2019
Izzak
Toyota Prius 2011
Bahar was flexible and helpful, and I saved a lot on gas because the car is a hybrid.
Izzak N. - October 8, 2018
Daniel
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom was a great host. The car surpassed all expectations and was delivered in pristine condition. He even picked me up and dropped me off! Great experience all around
Daniel H. - August 6, 2018
Matthew
Honda Civic 2014
Aquarius was a pleasure to coordinate with, and the car worked like a charm. I would recommend him to anyone
Matthew K. - August 9, 2018
susan
Honda Civic 2014
Very happy with renting this vehicle! It was clean ;and pick up and drop off was easy!
Susan K. - August 7, 2018
Helen
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
All-in-all a great experience! The car was very clean and a lot of fun to drive. Tom was incredibly communicative and very flexible when traffic pushed back my return time. Will definitely use this car again!
Helen M. - August 19, 2018
Tom
Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class 2016
Fan is a pleasure to work with. She is quick to respond, and incredibly accommodating. I highly recommend renting from her!
Tom A. - September 10, 2018
Bryan
Toyota Prius 2011
Bahsr's Prius was clean and comfortable. Took the car to Niagara Falls and around Lake Ontario. A joy to drive and very efficient with gas. Would definately recommend it.
Bryan T. - August 26, 2018
Kimberly
Lexus IS 250 2007
The car was very nice & Aquarius is very reliable & flexible..
Kimberly F. - October 30, 2018
John
Audi S4 2011
Jake was just as cool as our first interaction. Will definitely rent again.
John H. - October 11, 2018
Sean
Lexus IS 300 2017
Amazing car. In and out. Elvis was top notch in communication and just a overall pleasant guy. Amazing experience.
Sean G. - October 29, 2018
Samuel
Toyota Prius 2011
Excellent communication and a flawless car. Would highly recommend!
Samuel S. - October 30, 2018
Alex
Honda Accord 2007
Great car, smooth ride, and Melissa’s exceptionally helpful. Totally happy with this pick!
Alex Z. - November 11, 2018
Robert Darnell
Porsche 911 2006
Alvaro was a great host. Very clear process to receive car. The car was extremely clean and well maintained, I would recommend this host to everyone..
Robert Darnell J. - March 25, 2019
Levi
Audi S4 2011
Jake is an amazing host and his car is brilliant. Drives like new. Highly recommend!!!!
Levi H. - March 12, 2019
Oscar
Honda Accord 2007
Great reliable car, Melissa great to communicate with!
Oscar M. - November 3, 2018
Ryan
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2010
Danielle’s Benz is so fun to drive. She was easy to get in contact with throughout the trip and was flexible with the drop off time. My only criticism is the drivers side door handle wasn’t working On the inside which was a noticeable inconvenience.
Ryan R. - January 2, 2019
John
Lexus IS 300 2017
Elivs was very accommodating from beginning to end. Would definitely rent again.
John H. - December 31, 2018
Steven
Mercedes-Benz E-Class 2015
Isaac’s Mercedes is fabulous, drives so smooth. I may have to rent it again! And Isaac being available to talk me through anything...real comfortable service!
Steven J. - January 7, 2019
Daniel
Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class 2007
Thanks again! Great car and great host. Even helped me rush to the train station to make my train with two minutes to spare!
Daniel H. - February 25, 2019
Moriah
Toyota Prius 2011
Great experience with Bahar’s car. Easy pick up and return. Communication was fast and the car in great condition!
Moriah F. - November 19, 2018
James
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Easy pickup and return, Tom was very nice and flexible (worked around our train times for pickup and drop off). Car was clean, fun to drive and stylish.
James C. - December 24, 2018
Josh
Toyota Prius 2011
Easy communication. I’d definitally use this car again
Josh B. - September 25, 2018
Izzak
Lexus IS 250 2007
Loved the car. Clean and sleek looking. Handled well.
Izzak N. - October 15, 2018
Stephen
Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class 2007
Tom was great with the dropping off the car in a timely matter! Beautiful car, that rides great, and is fun to drive. Can’t wait to book the car again!
Stephen O. - February 10, 2019
Wesley
Audi S4 2011
Car was nice and Jake was a great host.
Wesley U. - March 13, 2019
Marvella
Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class 2007
Tom is a great host!! Great, fun car!!
Marvella H. - May 25, 2019
Irving
Ford Fusion 2011
The car was exactly what we were looking for! Darin's great communication made pickup and drop off very easy. The car ran great, got decent gas mileage, and was comfortable.
Irving G. - June 3, 2019
Emily
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom was a great host and the Mini Cooper was the perfect car our weekend get away! I would 100% book with Tom again. The car was very clean, drive well and Tom was very accommodating, picked us up from the train station and also dropped us off for our way back home.
Emily M. - May 19, 2019
Ajenae
Nissan Maxima 2009
He was awesome & Super Kind . Easy sailing .
Ajenae A. - July 2, 2019
Morgan
Toyota Prius 2011
Bahar is great. Was willing to be flexible with meeting me at the train station for drop off. Really appreciated that because we had to catch a train. All in all great experience. Would highly reccomend
Morgan W. - August 13, 2018
Diana
Mercedes-Benz E-Class 2011
Wonderful experience using Turo for the first time!
Diana A. - August 20, 2018
Nate
MINI Cooper Countryman 2011
Tom was great overall. Zippy experience in the Mini and smooth pickup and dropoff, rock on!
Nate U. - May 26, 2019
Daniel S
FIAT 500 2012
Easy to talk to and excellent customer service
Daniel S R. - June 9, 2019
Jason
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2016
Wonderful experience For My 1st time Tryin this....Timothy was Very Professional and I Felt very comfortable wit the Vehicle....I'll definitely be Back.....
Jason H. - May 24, 2019