Car rental alternatives in Indianapolis, IN

Better value, better cars

Wherever your trip takes you, book the perfect car, conveniently and affordably.

Convenient delivery

Get your car delivered to you, saving time and hassle

The perfect car

Choose the exact car you want — from swishy sports cars to sturdy sedans

More bang for your buck

Book a better car for up to 35% less than traditional car rental agencies

Top hosts in Indianapolis, IN

David A./>
David A. All-Star Host
1,280 trips Joined Jul 2013
Typically responds in 18 minutes

Recent reviews

Clean car, great mpg's and David was easy to communicate with and very helpful! I will reach out to him for my next Indy car rental!
Cameron - September 15, 2019
This was a painless car rental. David was flexible and the car met the specifications.
Mary - June 10, 2018

Average ratings in Indianapolis (4.9 stars)

Kia Soul 2017
Cleaner than some rental cars!
Shatona K. - February 12, 2019
Toyota Prius 2016
Clean car, great mpg's and David was easy to communicate with and very helpful! I will reach out to him for my next Indy car rental!
Cameron H. - September 15, 2019
Hyundai Sonata 2016
This was my first trip. Bill was patient and accommodating. The car was great. I would definitely rent a car from Bill again.
Theresa D. - August 17, 2019
Toyota Prius 2016
This was a painless car rental. David was flexible and the car met the specifications.
Mary K. - June 10, 2018
Nissan Versa 2012
Very clean car rental! He is a very nice & professional veteran who seriously takes care of his car. I would definitely rent from him again.
Sabrina C. - September 25, 2018
Honda Insight 2014
This was my first time renting through Turo, and it was a great experience! I liked that I was dealing with a individual and not a big box company treats you like a number. David was great at communicating and was very helpful with all questions even though the app was not working for me. Car was cool! No problems. Would definitely use this service and David again if the opportunity presented itself.
Kate E. - October 7, 2019
Honda Civic 2014
Where do I begin with this guy😁. My trip using Michaels car was very last minute. To my surprise, Michael had no issues renting out his awesome car with little notice to him. He was pleasant when I picked up the car and even more pleasant when I dropped off his car. His car was perfect for my trip and I couldn’t have chosen the perfect person and car. Michael! Thank you so much for everything and I look forward to doing business with you again. I will definitely rent from you again😁..
Ace F. - October 2, 2019
BMW 5 Series 2011
Vanessa was on time to drop car off curb side and meet me at curb side when I was leaving. Super easy and car was great. Much better than renting from traditional car rental
Todd R. - December 16, 2018
Honda Insight 2010
Great service. I could not be happier. It was a last minute trip and was thrilled to be able to book a car instantly and have the car conveniently waiting for me when I landed. Way easier than a traditional car rental service.
Laurie A. - September 29, 2018
Kia Soul 2017
Mike was a great! He made my first experience with turo simple and easy. I rented his Kia Soul which was very clean and drove perfectly. He was flexible and responded promptly when I requested to extend my trip for another day. I recommend him for your car rental needs and would do business with him myself in the future.
Brett B. - January 23, 2019
Honda Insight 2010
Once again, David delivered the best rental experience on everything. Love renting his cars and trucks!
Robert B. - August 3, 2019
Toyota Corolla 2016
David is a great host with great cars for any occasion, I can not recommend him more. Thanks David! I’ll be back!
Elaine R. - September 22, 2019
Toyota Camry 2013
Andrew’s Camry was very clean and well maintained. He was very responsive with impeccable instructions. There were several small dings but nothing that bothered us on the car. This was our first Turo rental but it won’t be our last! Will look for Andrew next time we’re in Indianapolis.
David C. - August 14, 2019
Toyota Camry 2013
We had a wonderful trip with Andrew's car. It was clean, and had a lot of care given to customers. There was even a pair of sunglasses inside! He was easy to communicate with and accommodated us greatly. Thanks Andrew!
Jonathan L. - September 30, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
Andrew made everything easy and the car was reliable! I’m very happy with the trip. Thank you!
Clint L. - September 27, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
Great car! This is the second time we have rented it. David is friendly and communicative and we’ve never had an issue renting from him. We will definitely rent again next time we are in Indy!
Amrah A. - October 3, 2019
FIAT 500 2017
Omg what an Amazing renter ! Quick communication, super flexible on time , very clean and nice looking car! Super fun to drive too and I would love to rent from Colleen again , highly recommend her to anyone that's looking for a car!
Michael W. - October 7, 2019
Toyota Prius 2016
Well, first time trying out Turo. I wasn't even in Indianapolis three hours and somebody stole the dang Prius! What a nightmare come true! Talk about throwing a major wrench in my work trip. David was a champ. He made came right away to fill out a police report and pick up the key FOB late at night. Turo was 0 help and treated me like I was the criminal that stole it. David was willing to lend me another car, but Turo refused pending an "investigation". Nobody from Turo showed up for said investigation and I was stranded trying to find rides and a different rental. Thank you ALAMO! David, thank you. The Prius was beautiful for the 30 minites I drove it. If it is found and my deceased boss's posters are in it bu some miracle please call me.
Heather M. - August 19, 2018
Toyota Camry 2008
Andrew is the best. He understands/communicates clearly on a timely basis. He truly cares and ais to exceed expectations, which he blew away. A great rental...job well done Andrew!
David H. - August 2, 2019
Toyota Prius 2016
The Prius was an amazing vehicle for my trip. David responded quickly to my messages and was easy to communicate with after I landed. Clean vehicle and easy to drive.
Lauren L. - September 19, 2019
Toyota Camry 2008
Andrew is a great communicator providing help at every step along the way On my next trip to Indy I will for sure use his autos.
Donald S. - September 21, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
I needed a car to make life a little less stressful with working and everything worked out. And this week seemed really stress free because I could get yo work easier.
Margret G. - September 20, 2019
Volkswagen Jetta 2016
Very fast at responding and good size car, enjoyed my time in Indy.
Stephanie L. - September 21, 2019
Toyota Camry 2009
Car runs great I had no problems
Samuel H. - September 24, 2019
Toyota Camry 2010
Andrew makes other Turo hosts look like amateurs. It’s because he’s a pro at what he does! When the car I had arranged was delayed 3+ hours away, he had me ready to go with a newer, nicer vehicle seamlessly. He just operates at a higher level. I would not hesitate to book with Andrew again.
Matthew J. - September 24, 2019
Lincoln MKZ 2015
Bryan and his incredible whip of a car were quite simply the best rental experience I’ve had in 28 years of business travel. The car is INCREDIBLE, I’m now in the market for a Lincoln hybrid sedan!, but Bryan is equal to the wagon. His willingness to keep me informed and work with me on the return was unparalleled and greatly appreciated. This is your Indy car, unless you are actually driving in the 500...
Daniel S. - August 13, 2019
Honda Insight 2010
I could not agent a rental car from the normal agencies for my trip. David’s Honda Insight made this trip haste free and convent. The car gets awesome gas mileage and David was a great communicator!
Stanford S. - August 23, 2019
Toyota Corolla 2016
This guy knows his business. Rent from him.
Henry K. - September 24, 2019
Ford Fusion Hybrid 2018
Awesome. He is renting for first time. Seamless experience. Amazing
Pranay S. - September 28, 2019
Ford Mustang 2015
Great to work with! I was supposed to pick the vehicle up, and they delivered it to my doorstep early and free of charge. Would definitely rent from them again, no question!
Jeffrey C. - September 30, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
The car was in great shape and the pick up and return process was very easy. Andrew communicated everything very thoroughly which was great!
Alec T. - October 7, 2019
Ford Mustang 2017
Trey is great & his Car might be, greater ! 👍
Amara L. - September 24, 2019
Hyundai Elantra 2013
Sukesh was awesome to work with. He was able to get us well made car seats and communication was really easy.
Ashleigh F. - October 8, 2019
Toyota Camry 2013
Andrew was great! Super responsive and kind. Had no issues with the car either, it was clean & ran well.
Rashid A. - October 3, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
David is very helpful and answers all questions! A nice car and very affordable. Thank you!
Nora G. - October 14, 2019
Toyota Corolla 2016
David was amazing, good car, awesome communication !!! Recommended
Omar G. - October 12, 2019
Toyota Camry 2010
He made it such a simple process, especially for a first time renter!
Ivy L. - October 10, 2019
Toyota Camry 2009
This was my first time using Turo and Andrew made the process effortless with detailed communication. Everything was very convenient. There was even a one size fits all phone case in the car with extra charging cables and an auxiliary cable in the middle console.
Michael R. - October 15, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
Andrew is GREAT to rent from for many reasons! From communication to being flexible he provides a positive experience!
Gabriel O. - October 16, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
I am a first time ever Turo user. I have for years used Dollar rental car company as a loyal "Dollar Express" member for years. I was VERY apprehensive about using Turo, but what you pay in airport tax fees, etc with the big rental car companies is truly ridiculous. Moreover, all the rental car company rates keep going up and up. I was planning a trip to the midwest for a month, and I contacted David about renting his Prius vehicle for my said trip. Being a first time Turo user, I had a lot of questions, and David was the utmost respectful and BEYOND patient taking the time to answer everyone of my questions prior to my even renting the vehicle. He is a GREAT communicator and very prompt in responding. Thus, I went ahead and rented said vehicle, and David made everything so easy from pick-up to drop-off. The car was "GREAT!!!" So efficient and so well kept. David even had new tires put on it prior to my rental for the full month. I drove Indianapolis to Cincy to Columbus to Cleveland and back to Indianapolis for my month trip in the midwest visiting family/relatives. Total gas i put in David's awesome, efficient vehicle was a total of $61.00. I drive at home a "gas guzzling," and "money drinking" SUV, and I have now become a BIG Prius fan. David's car is EXCELLENT, and you cannot go wrong booking with David. He is a GREAT communicator, beyond POLITE and COURTESY. I will be a REPEAT customer of David's vehicle. I HIGHLY recommend him. Thank you very much David!
Mark F. - September 5, 2018
Toyota Prius 2010
Great renting from David. Car is clean and everything co.completely functional. He gave us choices for pick up in Garage or economy lot. Great rental experience!
Carlie S. - July 27, 2019
BMW 5 Series 2012
Reilin was very flexible and asked for our flight info ahead of time . Even after being at work in operating room all day he was still already waiting for us at the arrivals curb before our plane landed. A very professional and enjoyable renting experience!! His car was in great condition and we couldn’t have asked for a better car for our trip . We will be back soon and will be reaching out to turo to rent with Reilin again on our next visit .
Christine D. - July 22, 2019
Faith Alden
Honda Insight 2014
He worked so well with me. Communication was open and I really appreciated that
Faith Alden B. - September 23, 2019
Hyundai Sonata 2016
Highly recommended. Always a pleasure.
Kendra S. - September 24, 2019
Volkswagen Jetta 2016
Mohriz was very punctual and helpful! We rented his VW Jetta for 4 days while visiting Indiana. The car was amazing, clean and everything worked great! Looking forward to the next trip *10/10 Experience*
Shea O. - August 24, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
Andrew was an amazing host! The car was clean and drove amazing. I routinely drove from the south side up to the north side and barely saw the gas meter move, excellent gas mileage! Andrew was very easy to contact, and very accommodating to any changes. This was my first Turo trip, and it certainly won’t be my last. I’ll be renting from Andrew again next time I’m in Indy, for sure!
Clint L. - August 19, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
Andrew made the pickup/drop off a breeze. Added little extra like cords. The car was pristine and drove like a charm. I highly recommend Andrew for your rental needs.
Patrick C. - August 21, 2019
Lincoln MKZ 2015
This is a very nice car for the money. It is very classy inside and out. It had all the necessary things like gps, bluetooth etc. Bryan left 2 phone chargers for us too which we always find we need! We had to change drop off and pick up times due to Hurricane Dorian and Bryan couldn’t have been more flexible. I would definitely get this car again if I came back to Indianapolis.
Renee K. - September 10, 2019
Honda Insight 2014
Tip top as usual! David is now my favorite host! Everything went so smoothly. I love it!
Edith G. - September 29, 2019
Toyota Corolla 2016
Amazing host! Very flexible and professional!
Jessica G. - September 29, 2019
Toyota Prius 2016
David’s Prius was perfect- drives well, economical. Airport pickup and drop off easy and stress free. Communication quick and accurate. Thanks David!
Bob D. - October 6, 2019
Toyota Camry 2013
Very easy to work with and communicated every step of the way!
David L. - October 6, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
My experience with David and his Prius were awesome! Whenever I had a question he would respond within minutes, and he was flexible about changing my return time a little later that day! Definitely going to be using his services again when I return!
Alexa P. - October 1, 2019
Latasha Lynn
Toyota Camry 2010
Very nice guy with quick response.
Latasha Lynn T. - October 3, 2019
Hyundai Sonata 2018
Shelby was very prompt, professional, helpful and friendly. Pickup and drop off instructions were detailed and easy. I particularly liked the adaptive cruise control feature on this vehicle!
Graham H. - October 3, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
The Prius is a Great Ride, sporty, cute and wonderful on gas! My experience was Perfect and David is Excellent!!
Misty H. - October 12, 2019
Mr Craig
Toyota Prius 2016
Wow! Did not realize how much I would enjoy driving a prius! Thanks so much
Mr Craig D. - October 7, 2019
Tesla Model 3 2018
Patrick was amazing, he was outside waiting for me as soon as I got off the plane and he also was waiting at airport departures so all I had to do was get out of the car and walk into the airport. The ease of everything alone was worth the price and not to mention his Tesla is the coolest car. Honestly can’t think of a single think he could have done to make this process any easier.. I used auto pilot all the way down to Lafayette and all the way back to Indy Will never use car rental company in Indy ever again Thanks Patrick
DUSTIN K. - February 8, 2019
Tesla Model 3 2018
I made a deal with my wife that if we were going to drive to visit her dad 90 min away from Indy, we needed to rent a cool car. The Tesla delivered. Loved the autopilot feature and how techie the whole vehicle was!! Patrick made our first experience on Turo a breeze!
Steve H. - April 15, 2019
Jaguar XF 2009
Great time with the car and Charles was kind and helpful. Will definitely reccomend and rent again on next trip to Indianapolis.
Allison A. - July 8, 2018
Honda Insight 2010
I was in PHL flying to IND and decided about an hour before departure I wanted a car. The big rental companies were no help, but David made it happen. Before the plane left the ground, the car was reserved. David provided detailed instructions to pick up the car in the parking garage and I was off. The only hiccup was the app crashing! The value-for-dollar of this experience is unmatched. A line-in cable to the radio and USB charging port were also provided in the clean, fully-fueled vehicle. If you are in Indianapolis and need a car fast, contact David.
Eric H. - April 5, 2019
Honda Insight 2010
It was my first time experience with Turo and David as my first car experience. can I triple the 5 star experience? this was far the best experience I have ever had. the communication was by far the best. david was awesome in keeping in touch with me. the wow factor is picking up the car at the airport. It can't get any better than that. the was very clean and drove very nicely around the city to from all destinations. and the drop off was great as well as the closing procedures. very simple very quick and very easy. I am Hooked!!! and when I come back to Indianapolis, David you are my choice no doubt. thank you so much for a great experience. you made my visit above all, the best!
Ronald B. - March 15, 2019
Francis Pierce
Toyota Prius 2010
David could not have made it easier. The car was exactly where it needed to be when I needed it, and the pickup process was much easier and faster than going through a rental service at the airport. David even included the cost for the parking lot in the fee, so there was a $10 bill waiting for me when I picked the car up. This was a small touch that made it clear to me I was in for a good experience. The car was as-advertised. It drove well and got great gas mileage, and was spotless when I picked it up. Even had an aux cord all plugged in for me to use. I’d definitely rent from David again if I’m going to Indianapolis!
Francis Pierce E. - October 13, 2018
Mercedes-Benz C-Class 2016
Trey was great to deal with, awesome car, there was a discrepancy in the rental and he resolved it right away to make sure I was happy with the whole experience, definitely recommend
John S. - May 27, 2019
Hyundai Sonata 2016
Bill made my first Turo experience a great one. The car was immaculate when I received it. He added in a few treats for the trip and made the return as easy as possible. When I need another rental, I am contacting Bill!
Steve S. - June 14, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
David was accommodating and a great communicator. He'a got a great system for pick up and drop off at the airport and I had no trouble finding the car. I would highly recommend this rental. There was a slight shimmy when speeds exceeded 55. He offered to get it taken care of while we had the car, but I was unable to respond until after we completed the trip. I'm sure he'll get it taken care of before next rental.
Terri W. - June 22, 2019
Honda Insight 2010
David was very helpful and explained plans very well - the car was as represented no surprises- great trip.
Mike B. - July 29, 2019
Tesla Model S 2013
Scott was friendly and car was in best condition and as clean as could be
Jesse P. - August 1, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
This was my first time using Turo. David, the host, explained everything I needed to know and answered all my questions. His car was clean and performed perfectly for the duration of the trip. Very positive experience all round.
Joseph R. - August 6, 2019
Honda Civic 2013
Jacqui was super pleasant , loved the car will rent again !!
Stacia A. - July 23, 2019
Toyota Prius 2010
Car was perfectly cleaned and worked great. 10/10 would rent another car from David
Ruben R. - August 14, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
Andrew was able to help me in a bind. I had rented from him when my car was in shop and it unexpectedly had to go back. I requested to rent again that morning. He responded within 5 mins and had the vehicle ready for pick up with 45 mins. His flexibility exceeded my most optimistic expectations. I wanted the Turo public to know that Andrew is amazing!
Patrick C. - September 9, 2019
Ford Flex 2011
Shelby is a friendly and helpful host. His prompt replies made me felt secure throughout the trip. His car is spacious enough for my 5 pcs of medium to large baggage. I definitely recommend others to book his car for an enjoyable trip!
Owen L. - August 21, 2019
Toyota Camry 2013
Andrew was very helpful during the rental process making this first time experience very easy and quick. I definitely would rent again from him if needed.
Claudia G. - August 17, 2019
Buick Regal 2017
I had a great experience renting Trey's Regal. He provided detailed instructions regarding pickup/dropoff, which ended up being easy and convenient. The car was perfect for what I needed it for and the option to have free parking in downtown was a nice perk.
Robert T. - September 9, 2019
Toyota Camry 2012
Everything was just as it should have been. This was my first Turo experience and Andrew's support makes me confident to do it again. Much easier than traditional rentals, and Andrew offers excellent communication. It could not have been better.
Larrin R. - September 13, 2019
Hyundai Sonata 2016
Bill was very nice, accommodating, and quick with communication! The car was clean and in perfect condition. Will definitely rent from Bill again.
Tony W. - September 1, 2019
Honda S2000 2007
David was great! He went above and beyond for me which was greatly appreciated. Car was fantastic! Made my first trip on Turo seemless!!! Would recommend David and his car to anyone!!!
Jeremy T. - September 14, 2019
Chevrolet Corvette 2018
Sean was a great renter, convenient pickup location and punctual. The car was handed off washed and gas full. The 2018 Corvette z06 was the best car I've rented on Turo yet, and that list is strong. This car is brand new, and was the top-of-the-line Corvette in 2018. The engine noise, acceleration and driving experience is simply AMAZING. The cars color and look is a serious head turner. The different driving modes (Touring, Sport, ..) really make this accessible to drivers wanting comfort not normally found in this level of sports car. This is a dream car.
David W. - April 27, 2018
Chevrolet Corvette 2018
The car was everything we expected and much more. If you like to be the center of attention, this car will turn heads every time you pull up. The car was excellent and the service was even better. Pickup and drop-off were smooth and effortless. If I'm ever in the Indianapolis area again, I will definitely be renting from Sean again.
Jonathan L. - April 29, 2018
Chevrolet Corvette 2018
The car was absolutely amazing! I have rented a number of nice cars but nothing as powerful or as impressive as this. The car was immaculate from top to bottom. Definitely will rent again next time I’m in Indy. Sean was great to work with as well, very prompt responses to all messages and the rental request and very accommodating to meeting location and times for pickup and drop off. I highly recommend you give this car a try! Thanks again for the great experience Sean
Jordan S. - May 8, 2018
Mitsubishi Lancer Sportback 2010
I had a real great time renting Tony's Lancer. Easy, clear communication, hassle-free, and the car performed wonderfully. I'll definitely be renting this one again when I'm in Indianapolis. Thanks Tony!
Conor P. - May 3, 2018
Toyota Camry 2008
Andrew has done a great job of making the process simple! The vehicle ran VERY well on our multi-state trip. It was free of creaks, groans, dash board idiot lights, and other worrisome events. The exterior looked okay (lower budget autobody work), one of the headlights seemed a little less than full power (probably not adjusted to full direction), and it smelled a little like a smoked in car (which the drivers seat also indicated). However, the longer we used it the more it smelled like us as professional customers. Other than disclosure for other customers, I wouldn’t even bother listing these things as they were absolutely live with issues for us. We will be glad to rent from Andrew again.
Daniel H. - May 30, 2018
Chevrolet Corvette 2018
I rented this car as a surprise for my husband for Father’s Day. It was a hit and he loved it. The car was immaculate and super fun to drive! Sean was great to work with and the online app made the whole process smooth. If you want to add a driver to your rental, have them set up a Turo account before you add them. It makes it easier. We would totally rent this again. Thanks for a great trip!
Alexandria N. - June 18, 2018
Chevrolet Corvette 2018
What a great experience from beginning to end! The Z06 is a beast and gets lot of love on the street. Thanks for making my first rental one I won't forget and for being a part of the Indianapolis Turo family. I'll definitely be renting again!
David A. - August 4, 2018
BMW 3 Series 2008
This car and Robert were amazing! Took a short trip and had great weather to put the top down! This Beamer drives like a dream and left nothing desired! Pickup & return was seamless and organized. If Robert doesn’t take this car off the rental block, I’d for sure get it again! Thanks Robert & Jesse!
Patrick P. - August 31, 2018
Lincoln MKZ 2015
Best rental ever! The car ride is so smooth. It's like it drives itself. Would definitely recommend and rent from Bryan again.
Robert B. - April 20, 2019
Toyota Prius 2016
I visit Indianapolis for business periodically. David is my go to guy for renting a car. Always a smooth experience.
Anderson S. - November 18, 2018
smart fortwo 2013
I am giving 5 stars simply because Trung handled everything well and all went well in the end and I saved a little money. But my review is a bit mixed because without the $25 first trip discount I would not have saved enough money to prefer this option over a standard rental agency. Also, while Trung's car is fine for your city needs, I cannot recommend using a Smart Car on the highway - especially not in the rain and wind (my experience) and absolutely not if there had been ice or snow. Maybe that is already obvious to most people, but I wanted to know how a smart car would do, so that was part of the experience, but I will not be seeking one to buy or borrow again.
Jon S. - October 15, 2018
Toyota Camry 2008
My first experience with turo was great. Andrew had the car there in plenty of time, gave clear instructions, and was very helpful throughout the trip. I would definitely recommend his vehicle to anyone who is looking for transportation in the Indianapolis area.
Austin Y. - January 19, 2019