Car rental alternatives in Arcata, CA

Better value, better cars

Wherever your trip takes you, book the perfect car, conveniently and affordably.

Convenient delivery

Get your car delivered to you, saving time and hassle

The perfect car

Choose the exact car you want — from swishy sports cars to sturdy sedans

More bang for your buck

Book a better car for up to 35% less than traditional car rental agencies

Average ratings in Arcata (5 stars)

Rob
Toyota Yaris 2014
We really enjoyed having this vehicle for local travel compared to using a commercial car rental at the Eureka/Arcata airport. Would rent again!
Rob B. - June 11, 2019
Colton
Toyota Yaris 2012
Good car, great host - Brandon is a very resourceful and generous guy. Highly recommend
Colton M. - October 27, 2019
Jonipher
Toyota Yaris 2012
Great ride as always. Really appreciate everything!
Jonipher K. - November 10, 2019
Veruma
Toyota Yaris 2012
I had that best time renting Brandon’s Toyota Yaris. The car was super clean, I had safe trip to the Bay Area, with impressive gas mileage. Brandon was super nice and I definitely recommend renting a car with him.
Veruma M. - May 31, 2019
Joseph
Toyota Yaris 2014
always a smooth rental experience with brandon!
Joseph P. - September 3, 2019
Jonipher
Toyota Yaris 2012
Brandon was a great communicator from beginning to end. He was able to pick me up and drop me off at the airport which was super convenient. The car itself was awesome and the whole process very smooth. I will definitely rent from him again in the future!
Jonipher K. - September 23, 2019
Doreen
Toyota Yaris 2014
First, Brandon was wonderful to rent from. He's laid-back yet clear and easy to communicate with. He was a pleasure to rent from. Second, the Toyota Yaris was a fantastic little car. I drove it from Arcata to Santa Rosa and into San Francisco. The car has everything you need. It was super clean and had really good gas mileage. It was great having a compact in the city. I'd certainly rent from Brandon again.
Doreen H. - February 26, 2019
Keiyon
Toyota Yaris 2014
Brandon’s Yaris was great just as described. The best part of the car was the fuel economy the thing sips gas. Brandon was even kind enough to bump up my rental date(had issues renting from another company). If you are in the Eureka area I suggest renting from Brandon.
Keiyon N. - March 20, 2019
NJ From
Toyota Matrix 2010
Best Turo host in Humboldt! Very professional and friendly. Book with Brandon!
NJ From F. - August 26, 2019
Lidia
Toyota Yaris 2012
We had a great time and Brandon was great! I booked last minute and he still answered within minutes and gave us suggestions of where to go in the area. The car was super clean, awesome with gas and I appreciated Brandon me walking through my first rental experience. If we are back in the area I would rent again! Lidia
Lidia S. - March 23, 2019
Rhonwen
Toyota Yaris 2014
This was my first trip using Turo and Brandon made it a great experience. He was kind, accommodating, and responsive... an excellent communicator. The car was sparkling clean and made for a really smooth trip. Thanks again, Brandon!
Rhonwen J. - June 18, 2019
Vance
Toyota Matrix 2010
Fantastic host!!! Easy booking, easy pickup, easy return. Would definitely rent from again, in fact I've already booked my next trip from this host.
Vance B. - June 2, 2019
Trillium
Toyota Yaris 2012
Brandon was great! Car was clean, in good repair, and got excellent gas mileage. This was my first time using Turo and Brandon was very helpful in assisting me in figuring out the app as well. Would definitely recommend renting from him!
Trillium S. - July 3, 2019
Joseph
Toyota Matrix 2010
always great doing business with brandon. i look forward to many rentals with him as i continue to be a travel nurse in humboldt county
Joseph P. - July 17, 2019
Lily Ellen
Toyota Yaris 2012
Great clean car and Brandon is an awesome host. Had a safe trip down to the bay with great gas mileage!
Lily Ellen S. - July 28, 2019
Veruma
Toyota Yaris 2014
It was my second time renting from Brandon. The car was perfect for our needs, it was very clean and fuel efficient. Brandon was great like always, he was able to accommodate my schedule perfectly and even picked me up at my bus stop. Thank you one more time, Brandon!
Veruma M. - July 11, 2019
Manders
Toyota Yaris 2012
Brandon was awesome! The little Yaris gets the best gas mileage and is a super reliable car. Couldn't ask for a better experience!
Manders A. - September 15, 2018
Erica
Toyota Yaris 2012
Nice car and saved me a lot on gas! Easy and fast. Would rent again.
Erica M. - December 19, 2018
Colton
Toyota Yaris 2014
Brandon and his car were great - he worked with me to accommodate my travel schedule and I highly recommend.
Colton M. - June 22, 2019
Adrienne
Toyota Yaris 2012
The car was great and picking it up and dropping it off was easy.
Adrienne F. - June 4, 2019
Deshonia
Toyota Yaris 2012
Brandon's car was awesome! The car was amazing on gas and was super clean inside and out, will be renting from him again next time I'm in Eureka :)
Deshonia H. - May 5, 2019
Honnah
Toyota Yaris 2014
Brandon was very helpful and accommodating. He even came and got us at the Airport when our flights got delayed till the next day, changing our plans. He gave us useful tips and was quick to respond to any questions I had. Easy going and friendly! Car ran great and was very clean. Great gas mileage and lots of space!
Honnah S. - May 31, 2019
Lisa
Toyota Yaris 2012
This was my first time using toro and Brandon was quick to respond and easy to communicate with through the process. Super simple pick up and return, clean, gas efficient car....a pleasant experience through and through! Thx Brandon!
Lisa C. - July 25, 2019
Joseph
Toyota Yaris 2014
this was my second time renting with brandon and my experience was as great as the first. i rent with him for business purposes and i plan to do with him many more times in the future! highly recommend him!
Joseph P. - July 3, 2019
David
Tesla Model S 2014
The Tesla was very awesome to drive. Especially in the Redwoods, where the quiet of an electric car was important. Tim was very accommodating to our needs with pick up and drop off.
David R. - July 4, 2018
Taylor
Tesla Model S 2014
This car is AMAZING. Thanks Timothy, can't wait to get behind the wheel again and drive the future.
Taylor D. - July 23, 2018
Ricardo
Toyota Prius Plug-in 2015
Near perfect ride. Scent of weed when first entering the car but I didn't mind too much. Goes away with the windows down.
Ricardo R. - September 2, 2018
Jessica
Toyota Prius Plug-in 2015
Thank you David for making me a Turo believer. Lol great, super smooth car.
Jessica A. - October 22, 2018
Jessica
Toyota Yaris 2014
Brandon made my otherwise stressful trip extremely easy and let pleasurable. My plans kept changing on me last-minute and Brandon accommodated each change with no hassle. I will certainly be recommending him and reusing his services in the future
Jessica K. - February 18, 2019
Scott
Toyota Matrix 2010
Needed a car, mine is in the shop.
Scott C. - December 15, 2018
Kimberly
Toyota Matrix 2010
Exactly what we needed to get around. My son now wants a Matrix for his college car!!!!
Kimberly W. - December 30, 2018
Robert
Toyota Yaris 2014
Great gas mileage and awesome get around car. Thanks Brandon!
Robert F. - March 10, 2019
Derek
Toyota Yaris 2014
Brandon was fantastic! The Yaris was practical and economical. A great Humboldt runabout.
Derek I. - May 20, 2019
Joseph
Toyota Yaris 2014
i work as a travel nurse and needed a car fast while my company couldn’t deliver on time. brandon was very flexible and accommodating. this was my first time using turo and so he made sure he walked me through the whole process. it was all very easy and hassle free. the yaris was a good car to drive around and very fuel efficient. would definitely do business with again!
Joseph P. - May 14, 2019
Joseph
Toyota Matrix 2010
always a great experience doing business with brandon. i look forward to many more reservations in the future!
Joseph P. - August 10, 2019
Vance
Toyota Yaris 2012
Great to work with, easy pickup and return.
Vance B. - June 11, 2019
Joseph
Toyota Yaris 2012
always a great time doing business with brandon!
Joseph P. - July 13, 2019
Karen
Tesla Model S 2014
What a beautiful and smooth ride. The host was more than accommodating and the experience was wonderful.
Karen V. - August 27, 2018
Amanda
Toyota Yaris 2014
Brandon was exceptionally helpful and accommodating.
Amanda F. - May 1, 2019