My Red 2009 Toyota Yaris 2 door hatchback (named Boop!) is clean and comfy, gets great gas mileage (high 20s in the city, 35+ on the highway), and can carry surprisingly large cargo for how small it looks. It has power windows and locks, keyless entry, rear seats that fold down, an audio input port and cable, and an oddly large number of small storage compartments and cupholders. There's a roadside assistance bag with flares, jumper cables, and a first aid kit in the trunk. I don't have a bike rack right now because most bikes actually fit inside if you take the front wheel off.
I can meet you at the Charlottesville airport (CHO) if our schedules work out, but you'll need to drive me home from there (9.5 miles, 20 minutes w/o traffic), and the same thing works in reverse. The cost for this (both ways included) is $20.