My Red 2009 Toyota Yaris 2 door hatchback (named Boop!) is clean and comfy, gets great gas mileage (high 20s in the city, 35+ on the highway), and can carry surprisingly large cargo for how small it looks. It has power windows and locks, keyless entry, rear seats that fold down, a trunk cargo area cover, an audio input port and cable, and an oddly large number of small storage compartments and cupholders. There's a roadside assistance bag with flares, jumper cables, and a first aid kit in the trunk. I don't have a bike rack right now because a bike actually fits inside if you take the front wheel off.
I can meet you at the Charlottesville airport (CHO) if our schedules work out, but you'll need to drive me home from there (9.5 miles, 20 minutes w/o traffic), and the same thing works in reverse. The cost for this (both ways included) is $20.