Become a host
  • Log in
  • Sign up
  • Become a host

  • How Turo works
  • Contact support
  • Legal
  • Protection
  • Host tools
  • Carculator

Car rental in Bay Shore, NY

Discover the Turo car rental marketplace

Where
From
Until
Car rentalUnited StatesBay Shore, NY
Insurance icon

Extraordinary selection

From standard cars to supercars, find the perfect car for any occasion or budget

Insurance icon

Liability insurance included

Third-party liability insurance comes standard, and choose from a range of vehicle protection plans

Free cancellation

Easy airport pickup

You can skip the rental counter at 100+ airports across the US and Canada

Top rated rental cars in Bay Shore, NY

Audi R8 2023 — Car rental alternative in Westbury, NY
Add car to favorites
Audi R8 2023

21 Feb - 24

Save USD195

$1,947USD1,752 total
Mercedes-Benz AMG GT 2019 — Car rental alternative in Bellerose, NY
Add car to favorites
Mercedes-Benz AMG GT 2019

5.0

(2 trips)

All-Star Host

21 Feb - 24

USD900 total

Browse by make

Jeep rental alternatives - TURO
Jeep
Tesla rental alternatives - TURO
Tesla
Subaru rental alternatives - TURO
Subaru
Porsche rental alternatives - TURO
Porsche
BMW rental alternatives
BMW
Mercedes-Benz rental alternatives - TURO
Mercedes-Benz
Toyota rental alternatives
Toyota
Nissan rental alternatives
Nissan
Lamborghini rental alternatives
Lamborghini
Ford rental alternatives
Ford
Bay Shore, EN

Car rental options in Bay Shore

Bay Shore, a charming coastal town on Long Island's South Shore, offers a perfect blend of seaside beauty and suburban convenience. With its picturesque waterfront, vibrant downtown, and proximity to stunning beaches, Bay Shore is an ideal destination for travelers seeking a relaxing getaway. Booking a rental car allows you to fully explore the town's hidden gems, nearby attractions, and scenic coastal drives, giving you the freedom to create unforgettable memories at your own pace.

Top hosts in Bay Shore, NY

Julian N.

Julian N.

All-Star Host
3110 tripsJoined
Excellent vehicle great price convenient pickup...
CAMERON P.-
The host demonstrated a high level of accommodation, ensuring that I comprehended the app and was readily available to address any inquiries or concerns.
Fiona A.-

Julian N.’s vehicles

Recent reviews

Ford Focus 2016

Great communication, car got the job done and had a little bit of a noise coming from it but didnt affect the driving much!

Kenia A.
-
Dehendra B.
Nissan Altima 2024

I always book this altima, the guy at the gas station is nice Nd he lets me get a free scent to add the the car.

Dehendra B.
-
Eric S.
Nissan Altima 2025

The car was great and pick up was easy.

Eric S.
-
Jennifer C.
Ford Fiesta 2016

Car is great on gas, runs good and clean.

Jennifer C.
-
Nissan Altima 2024

Love the rental.......Check out process was easy.

Mitchel J B.
-
Nestor C.
Toyota Camry 2023

Limit mileage kill the experience. (3 day rented trip to virginia) Cost same as i rent at the airport.

Nestor C.
-
Lexus IS 2021

Very accommodating and would recommend to anyone!

Chris C.
-
Sharyce H.
Hyundai Elantra 2019

Host was very pleasant and accommodating . Would book again

Sharyce H.
-
Aleksandra M.
Lamborghini Huracan EVO 2022

The car experience was amazing!

Aleksandra M.
-
Janet W.
Nissan Altima 2020

Very nice ride will definitely rent again.

Janet W.
-
Meryl F.
Ford Fiesta 2016

I rented his car last minute and he was so accommodating and pleasant.

Meryl F.
-
Dehendra B.
Nissan Altima 2024

Car was clean, drives well, this my second time booking.

Dehendra B.
-
Jonathan C.
Nissan Altima 2020

Car is phenomenal, clean and runs incredibly.

Jonathan C.
-
BMW 3 Series 2024

Car was very clean & drives great. really enjoyed the experience with this car.

Tyler W.
-
Dehendra B.
Nissan Altima 2024

Everything went well nd was able to return it back early nd extend my trip.

Dehendra B.
-
Jessica J.
Honda Civic 2013

Car was in creat condition.

Jessica J.
-

Discover Bay Shore's must-see attractions and activities

Bay Shore boasts an array of exciting experiences for visitors. From strolling along the scenic Fire Island ferries to exploring the historic downtown area, there's something for everyone. A rental car provides the flexibility to visit nearby beaches, enjoy waterfront dining, and venture to nearby parks and nature preserves. Whether you're interested in outdoor adventures or cultural experiences, having a car at your disposal ensures you won't miss out on any of Bay Shore's highlights.


Explore the natural beauty of Gardiner County Park

Gardiner County Park is a hidden gem nestled along the Great South Bay. This serene park offers visitors a chance to unwind amidst nature, with walking trails, picnic areas, and stunning bay views. Driving to the park is convenient, with ample parking available. As you cruise along the scenic route, keep an eye out for local wildlife and breathtaking coastal vistas. The park's location makes it an ideal spot for a leisurely afternoon or a memorable sunset picnic after a day of exploring Bay Shore.


Immerse yourself in history at the Sagtikos Manor

Step back in time at the Sagtikos Manor, a historic house museum that dates back to 1697. This beautifully preserved estate offers guided tours, showcasing centuries of Long Island history. Driving to the manor is straightforward, with on-site parking available for visitors. As you approach, you'll be greeted by the manor's impressive grounds and architecture. The flexibility of having a rental car allows you to combine your visit with other nearby attractions, making for a perfect day trip in Bay Shore.


Enjoy retail therapy at Westfield South Shore Mall

For those seeking a shopping adventure, Westfield South Shore Mall is a must-visit destination. This expansive shopping center features a wide array of stores, from popular brands to local boutiques. With a rental car, you can easily transport your purchases and explore other shopping areas in Bay Shore. The mall offers ample parking, making your visit hassle-free. After a day of retail therapy, you can use your rental car to discover nearby restaurants or take a relaxing drive along the coast.


How to reach Bay Shore for your vacation


- By plane: Fly into Long Island MacArthur Airport, then rent a car for a short drive to Bay Shore.
- By train: Take the Long Island Rail Road to Bay Shore station, then pick up your rental car nearby.
- By car: Drive along the Southern State Parkway or Sunrise Highway, depending on your starting point.


Essential advice for renting a car in Bay Shore

When booking a rental car in Bay Shore, consider reserving early on Turo to secure the best selection. Choose a car that suits your planned activities, whether it's a compact car for city driving or an SUV for beach trips. Look for extras like GPS navigation for easy exploration, or a bike rack if you plan to cycle along the coast. During summer, air conditioning is a must-have feature. Remember to check for cars with backup cameras or blind spot warnings for added safety while navigating Bay Shore's streets and parking areas.

Top cities

Brooklyn

Frequently asked questions in Bay Shore, NY

What are some popular pickup locations for rental cars in Bay Shore, and what should guests consider when choosing one?

Bay Shore offers several convenient pickup locations for rental cars. The downtown area near Main Street is a popular spot, with easy access to local attractions and dining options. Guests might also find pickup locations near the Bay Shore Marina, which is ideal for those planning water activities. When choosing a pickup location, consider proximity to your accommodation or planned activities. It's wise to check if the host on Turo offers delivery, as many provide this service for added convenience. Keep in mind factors like parking availability and traffic patterns in Bay Shore, especially during peak summer months. Some hosts may offer pickup near public transit hubs, making it easier for guests arriving without personal transportation. Always communicate with your host on Turo to arrange the most suitable pickup location for your Bay Shore car rental experience.

What are some pleasant driving routes near Bay Shore for a scenic day trip?

Bay Shore offers several picturesque driving routes for a delightful day trip. Consider exploring the scenic Ocean Parkway, which runs along the south shore of Long Island. This route provides stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean and access to beautiful beaches. Another option is the Montauk Highway, winding through charming coastal towns and offering glimpses of the bay. For a more rural experience, venture north to the Long Island Wine Country, where you can drive through rolling vineyards and quaint farm stands. Remember to rent a comfortable car suited for longer drives to fully enjoy these scenic routes around Bay Shore.

How can guests find convenient parking facilities in Bay Shore during their rental car stay?

Bay Shore offers various parking options for visitors with rental cars. The downtown area features several municipal lots and street parking, many with reasonable rates. For longer stays, consider the Bay Shore Marina parking lot, which provides ample space and scenic views. Some hotels in Bay Shore also offer parking for guests, so it's worth inquiring about this amenity when booking your accommodation. If you're planning to use public transportation for part of your trip, look into park-and-ride facilities near the Bay Shore train station. Always check parking signs carefully, as some areas have time limits or resident-only restrictions.

Are there any tolls to be aware of when driving around Bay Shore and Long Island?

When driving around Bay Shore and Long Island in your rental car, be prepared for several toll roads. The most notable is the Robert Moses Causeway, which connects Bay Shore to the barrier islands. Additionally, if you plan to venture further, you may encounter tolls on bridges and tunnels leading to New York City, such as the Throgs Neck Bridge or the Queens Midtown Tunnel. It's advisable to keep some cash on hand for toll payments, although many toll plazas now accept credit cards. Some rental cars may come equipped with E-ZPass transponders, which can make toll payments more convenient. Always factor potential toll expenses into your travel budget when planning your Bay Shore car rental experience.

Which car types are recommended for exploring Bay Shore and its surrounding areas?

For exploring Bay Shore and its surrounding areas, several car types can enhance your rental experience. A comfortable sedan is ideal for city driving and short trips around Long Island. If you're planning beach visits or outdoor adventures, consider renting an SUV, which offers more space for gear and better handling on varied terrain. For those seeking a more eco-friendly option, electric vehicles are becoming increasingly popular and can be a great choice for navigating Bay Shore's streets. If you're traveling with family or a larger group, a minivan might be the most practical choice, providing ample room for passengers and luggage. Ultimately, the best car for your Bay Shore adventure depends on your specific plans and preferences.

Where can guests find reliable gas stations in and around Bay Shore?

Bay Shore and its surrounding areas are well-equipped with reliable gas stations to keep your rental car fueled. You'll find several options along major roads such as Sunrise Highway and Montauk Highway. Popular chains like Shell, Mobil, and Sunoco have multiple locations in the area, offering convenience and consistency. For potentially lower prices, consider local independent stations or those associated with supermarkets. It's a good practice to refuel your rental car before embarking on longer trips, especially if you're heading to more remote areas of Long Island. Many gas stations in Bay Shore also offer convenience stores, making it easy to stock up on snacks and drinks for your journey.

What are some key differences between driving in Bay Shore versus navigating New York City streets?

Driving in Bay Shore offers a notably different experience compared to navigating New York City streets. Bay Shore features wider roads and less congested traffic, making for a more relaxed driving environment. Parking is generally easier to find and often free or less expensive than in the city. However, Bay Shore has fewer public transportation options, making a car rental more necessary for exploring the area. Unlike NYC's grid system, Bay Shore's street layout is less uniform, so relying on a GPS is recommended. Speed limits in Bay Shore are typically higher than in NYC, but always adhere to posted signs. Remember, while NYC is known for its aggressive driving culture, Bay Shore maintains a more laid-back atmosphere on the roads.

How should guests prepare for driving in various weather conditions common to Bay Shore?

When preparing to drive your rental car in Bay Shore, it's important to consider the diverse weather conditions you may encounter. In summer, be ready for potential heatwaves by ensuring your car's air conditioning is functioning properly. During fall and spring, be cautious of wet leaves on the road which can reduce traction. Winter in Bay Shore can bring snow and ice, so if renting during colder months, consider a car with all-wheel drive. Always check the weather forecast before setting out on longer trips. It's wise to familiarize yourself with your rental car's features, such as windshield wipers and defrosting systems, to ensure you're prepared for sudden weather changes common to this coastal area.

What are some essential tips for long-distance driving from Bay Shore to other parts of New York?

When embarking on long-distance drives from Bay Shore to other parts of New York in your rental car, preparation is key. First, plan your route in advance, considering potential traffic hotspots and alternative roads. Take regular breaks to stay alert, especially on longer journeys. Keep an eye on your fuel gauge and plan refueling stops, as gas stations can be sparse in some rural areas of New York. Be prepared for varying road conditions, from smooth highways to potentially rougher rural roads. If heading upstate, be aware that mountainous terrain may require different driving techniques. Always check your rental car's tire pressure and fluid levels before a long trip. Lastly, pack some snacks and water to keep yourself refreshed during the journey.

  1. * Any personal insurance you may have that covers damage to the host’s vehicle would kick in before your protection plan, except in limited situations for trips booked in Maryland, but this protects your own wallet. In the US, liability insurance is provided under a policy issued to Turo by Travelers Excess and Surplus Lines Company. Terms, conditions, and exclusions apply. The policy does not provide coverage for damage to a host’s vehicle.

  2. For questions or information about the third party liability insurance for trips in the US, consumers in Maryland and the licensed states listed here may contact Turo Insurance Agency at (415) 508-0283 or claims@turo.agency. For questions about how damage to a host’s vehicle is handled, visit the Turo Support site. When a trip is booked in the state of Washington, physical damage to the host’s vehicle is covered by insurance purchased by Turo, but the Turo insurance does not change the contractual responsibilities of hosts or guests with respect to physical damage to a host’s vehicle.